Quote by C.S. Lewis
Answers to leading questions under torture naturally tell us nothing about the beliefs of the accused; but they are good evidence for the beliefs of the accusers.
Summary
This quote highlights the inherent flaw in using answers obtained through torture as a means to understand the beliefs of the accused. It suggests that under extreme duress, individuals are likely to provide responses that please their torturers rather than reveal their own genuine beliefs. Therefore, the quote implies that such responses only reflect the beliefs of those conducting the torture, acting as evidence of their own convictions rather than shedding light on the true beliefs of the accused.
Topics
Torture
By C.S. Lewis